PM SOCIETY 2009 ADVERTISING AWARDS

29th January 2010


Dear Members and Guests

At the start of my second decade as your awards chairman, it’s my great pleasure to present this souvenir brochure of the results from the 24th Annual PM Society Advertising Awards, the event that never fails to lighten the gloom of a cold, dreary and this year snowy January!

2009 was a difficult year for many, so I was delighted that the quantity of entries held up from previous years and the quality in several categories was very high. Significantly and despite the inaugural PM Society Digital Media Awards held only a few months ago, there were as many digital entries as GP press advertisements – clearly reflecting the way our communications are changing.

Congratulations to all this year’s winners of whom Langland must be singled out for setting a new record for the number of categories (7) won by one agency since these awards began. The distinctive style of their work clearly found much favour with our creative judges.

My thanks as ever to our sponsors, our judges, my PM Society committee colleagues and of course yourselves - the reason this event exists at all. Finally I must say a word about Vivien Bennett, my invaluable assistant in organising this event. At the time of press it is unknown whether she will have been able to attend today - as she had an accident in December and has been housebound ever since. I’m sure you would like to join me in wishing her well.

On behalf the PM Society, may I wish you a successful 2010.


Neil Smith, PM Society Awards Chairman
Neil G P Smith
PM SOCIETY AWARDS CHAIRMAN

PM SOCIETY 2009 ADVERTISING AWARDS

Awards/Sponsors

TARGET AUDIENCE AWARDS


GP Journal Advertisement MJL Advertising
GP Direct Mail Cegedim Dendrite
Hospital Journal Advertisement Langland
Nursing Journal Advertisement PriMe
Healthcare Industry Advertisement PM Group

CRAFT AWARDS


GP Journal Advertisement Dark Horse Agency
Hospital Journal Advertisement The British Journal of Clinical Pharmacy
Nursing Journal Advertisement Nitrogen – A Huntsworth Health Company
Journal Advertisement Campaign Publicis Life Brands
Healthcare Professional Direct Mail PAN Advertising
Detailing Aid Ashfield In2Focus
Digital Media – Interactive Quintiles
Digital Media – Film Adventis Health
GP Campaign MGP Ltd
Hospital Campaign IMS Health
International Core Campaign Nitrogen Interactive – A Huntsworth Health Company
Patient Information Campaign KantarHealth


The PM Society is most grateful to all award sponsors and in addition to the following:
Sponsorship of Distribution of Awards Brochure – PharmaTimes
Sponsorship of AV Graphics – Genesis Adoration

The PM Society is also grateful for the help and support of:
Production and Staging – H2 Business Communication
Target Audience Research GP & Hospital Awards, Craft Online Research – KantarHealth
Provision of Craft Award Judging Facilities – BMJ Publishing Group

TARGET AUDIENCE JUDGED AWARD

GP Journal Advertisement

Sponsored by MJL Advertising

PositionAdvertisementCompanyAgency
1stBalneum PlusAlmirallSwordfish Advertising
2ndCalcichew D3 Forte Shire PharmaSwordfish Advertising
3rdExorex LotionForest Laboratories UKDDB Health
4thRelestatRecordati/AllerganAdventis Health
5thExorex Lotion (football)Forest Laboratories UKDDB Health
6thRelestat (flaming eyes)Recordati/AllerganAdventis Health
7thCalcichew D3 Forte (ice creams)Shire PharmaSwordfish Advertising

PositionAdvertisementVisual AppealMemorabilityAcceptabilityUsefulness (1)Superiority (2)Complementarity (3)Overall Rating
1stBalneum Plus2.001.742.462.221.381.861.94
2ndCalcichew D3 Forte1.901.702.082.281.241.481.78
3rdExorex Lotion2.362.121.261.951.181.561.74
4thRelestat2.181.761.921.831.181.401.71
5thExorex Lotion (football)2.281.861.471.410.961.121.52
6thRelestat (flaming eyes)2.371.841.071.590.731.241.47
7th Calcichew D3 Forte (ice creams)1.801.271.261.840.821.181.36
Notes: 1 As a reminder    2 Over other advertisements    3 Cohesion between copy and visual

TARGET AUDIENCE JUDGED AWARD

GP Direct Mail

Sponsored by Cegedim Dendrite

PositionMailingCompanyAgency
1stMalaroneGlaxoSmithKlinePAN Advertising
2ndEfraceaGaldermaRFA Advertising
3rdLaxidoGalenSwordfish Advertising
4thTetralysalGaldermaLife Healthcare
5thFostairChiesi UKSwordfish Advertising

PositionMailingVisual AppealMemorabilityAcceptabilityUsefulness (1)Superiority (2)Complementarity (3)Overall Rating
1stMalarone1.681.562.162.601.481.781.88
2ndEfracea1.041.061.261.560.920.981.14
3rd Laxido1.641.460.241.740.581.041.12
4thTetralysal1.080.920.420.510.600.460.67
5thFostair0.740.200.540.510.160.600.46
Notes: 1 As a reminder    2 Over other advertisements    3 Cohesion between copy and visual

TARGET AUDIENCE JUDGED AWARD

Hospital Journal Advertisement

Sponsored by Langland

PositionAdvertisementCompanyAgency
1stBetesilGenusBig Pink
2ndZoladex AstraZenecaBrand(x) Communications
3rdAvamysGlaxoSmithKlinePAN Advertising
4thSeroquel XLAstraZenecaLangland
5thNeuroblocEisai UKLangland
6thCaelyx (good hair day)Schering PloughLane Earl Cox

TARGET AUDIENCE JUDGED AWARD

Nursing Journal Advertisement

Sponsored by PriMe

PositionAdvertisementCompanyAgency
1stCaelyxSchering PloughLane Earl Cox
2ndBalneum PlusAlmirallSwordfish Advertising
3rdBetesilGenusBig Pink
4thWater GenieGenie CareDewar Advertising
5thCalcichew D3 ForteShire PharmaceuticalsSwordfish Advertising
6thChildren's VaccinesSanofi Pasteur MSDAdventis Health

TARGET AUDIENCE JUDGED AWARD

Healthcare Industry Journal Advertisement

Sponsored by PM Group

PositionAdvertisementAgency
WinnerLanglandLangland
Highly CommendedAdventis HealthAdventis Health
CommendedLife HealthcareLife Healthcare
CommendedOnMedicaLife Healthcare
NominatedPAN Advertising (Brand Aid)PAN Advertising
NominatedHealth CollectivePAN Advertising

JUDGING PANELS

Chairman all judging panels: Neil Smith, Adventis Health
 

HOSPITAL CAMPAIGN, DETAILING AID, INTERNATIONAL CORE CAMPAIGN, PATIENT INFORMATION CAMPAIGN

Harry Armfield
Lane Earl Cox

Chris Duncan
Pulsar

Philip Eaton
MJL Advertising
 
Lisa Edge-Davies
Creative Consortium

Julie Erens
Huntsworth Health

Dave Harris
PAN Advertising
 
Liz Maclaren
Concentric Advertising

Andrew Spurgeon
Langland
 

HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONAL DIRECT MAIL, GP CAMPAIGN, DIGITAL MEDIA

Malcolm Badger
Euro RSCG Life

Alan Cheeseman
Grand Fromage

Louise Harley
Saatchi & Saatchi Healthcare
 
Kate Hawkins
Creative Lynx

Matt Macland
VCCP Health

Reg Manser
Life Healthcare
 
Andrew Nicholson
Magnetic

Frank Walters
TBWA/Paling Walters

Dave Wyatt
Adventis Health

HEALTHCARE INDUSTRY ADVERTISEMENT AWARD

Russell Abberley
Schering Plough

TJ Bailey-Burnley
Basilea Pharmaceuticals

Victoria Bates
Wyeth Pharmaceuticals

Phil Carroll
Derma UK
 
Emma Childs
Abbott Laboratories

Claire Holman
Astellas Pharma Europe

Sarah Hutt
Napp Pharmaceuticals

Martin Lambert
Merck
 
Deb Lancaster
Roche Products

Tamsin Smith
Abbott Laboratories

Patrick Standen
Teva Pharmaceuticals
 

GEOFF BROOK AWARD FOR INNOVATION IN DIGITAL MEDIA

Steve Clark
SC Marketing

Karl Equi
PM Group

Rachel Farrow
Quintiles
 
Kevin McGetrick
Adventis Health

Craig Mills
McCann Healthcare

Sandy Royden
Huntsworth Health
 
Matt Tickner
Digitas Health

Jon Vernon
OnMedica

Colin Williams
PharmiWeb
 

GEOFF BROOK AWARD FOR DIGITAL INNOVATION

PositionEntryCompanyAgency
WinnerTygacil (Ward Invaders)WyethCreative Lynx
Runner UpEkeyGE HealthcareBig Pink
Runner UpLucentis Virtual ClinicNovartisCreative Lynx
Runner UpPsoriasis: The Naked TruthWyethOgilvy Health PR

CRAFT AWARD

GP Journal Advertisement

Sponsored by Dark Horse Agency

PositionAdvertisementCompanyAgency
WinnerPegasysRocheNitrogen - A Huntsworth Health Company
Highly CommendedPegasysRocheNitrogen - A Huntsworth Health Company
Highly CommendedXenicalRocheTBWA/Paling Walters
CommendedXenicalRocheTBWA/Paling Walters
NominatedViagraPfizerTBWA/Paling Walters
NominatedSymbicort Smart (Chaplin)AstraZenecaSaatchi & Saatchi Healthcare

CRAFT AWARD

Hospital Journal Advertisement

Sponsored by The British Journal of Clinical Pharmacy

PositionAdvertisementCompanyAgency
WinnerCompassSchering PloughLangland
Highly CommendedCompassSchering PloughLangland
Highly CommendedCompassSchering PloughLangland
NominatedSMA (football)WyethSeven Stones
NominatedSMA (balloon)WyethSeven Stones
NominatedZoladex (scorpion)AstraZenecaBrand(x) Communications

CRAFT AWARD

Nursing Journal Advertisement

Sponsored by Nitrogen - A Huntsworth Health Company

PositionAdvertisementCompanyAgency
WinnerChildren's VaccinesSanofi Pasteur MSDAdventis Health
Highly CommendedSMAWyethSeven Stones
CommendedSMAWyethSeven Stones
CommendedDesmomeltFerring PharmaeuticalsMJL Advertising
NominatedBetesil (Joan)Genus PharmaceuticalsBig Pink
NominatedUracyst (family bag)GalenSwordfish Advertising

CRAFT AWARD

Journal Advertisement Campaign

Sponsored by Publicis Life Brands

PositionCampaignCompanyAgency
WinnerCompassSchering PloughLangland
Highly CommendedSymbicort SmartAstraZenecaSaatchi & Saatchi Healthcare
CommendedSMAWyethSeven Stones
NominatedActifuseApatechSeven Stones
NominatedUracystGalenSwordfish Advertising
NominatedExorex LotionForest Laboratories UKDDB Health

CRAFT AWARD

Healthcare Professional Direct Mail

Sponsored by PAN Advertising

PositionMailingCompanyAgency
WinnerWarticonStiefel LaboratoriesWoolley Pau
CommendedDuacStiefel LaboratoriesWoolley Pau
CommendedFortisip CompactNutriciaCherry Advertising
CommendedMirapexinBoehringer IngelheimPAN Advertising
NominatedAvonexBiogen IDECSeven Stones

CRAFT AWARD

Detailing Aid

Sponsored by Ashfield In2Focus

PositionDetailing AidCompanyAgency
WinnerNeuroblocEisai UKLangland
CommendedAvonexBiogen IDECSeven Stones
CommendedKogenateBayerLangland
NominatedCaelyxSchering PloughLane Earl Cox
NominatedDesmomeltFerring PharmaceuticalsMJL Advertising
NominatedNebidoBayer ScheringTorre Lazur McCann

CRAFT AWARD

Digital Media - Interactive

Sponsored by Quintiles

PositionAdvertisementCompanyAgency
WinnerTygacilWyethCreative Lynx
CommendedAvamys WebsiteGSKCMP Medica & PAN Advertising
CommendedLyrinel eDetailJanssen-CilagBig Pink
NominatedLucentis Virtual ClinicNovartisCreative Lynx
NominatedSingulair MicrositeMSDVCCP Health

CRAFT AWARD

Digital Media - Film

Sponsored by Adventis Health

PositionAdvertisementCompanyAgency
WinnerChanging Faces of ADHDShire PharmaceuticalsMcCann Erickson Communications House
CommendedChloraprepCare FusionSeven Stones
CommendedLipitor (Fisherman)PfizerTBWA/Paling Walters
NominatedInovelonEisaiBig Pink
NominatedSeroquel AstraZenecaLangland

CRAFT AWARD

GP Campaign

Sponsored by MGP Ltd

PositionCampaignCompanyAgency
WinnerWarticonStiefel LaboratoriesWoolley Pau
CommendedNebidoBayer ScheringTorre Lazur McCann
CommendedRelestatRecordati/AllerganAdventis Health
NominatedSymbicort COPDAstraZenecaSaatchi & Saatchi Healthcare
NominatedSymbicort SmartAstraZenecaSaatchi & Saatchi Healthcare

CRAFT AWARD

Hospital Campaign

Sponsored by IMS Health

PositionCampaignCompanyAgency
WinnerCompassSchering PloughLangland
Highly CommendedAvonexBiogen IDECSeven Stones
Highly CommendedCaelyxSchering PloughLane Earl Cox
CommendedKogenateBayerLangland
NominatedCryogesicIS PharmaCreative Lynx
NominatedUracystGalenSwordfish Advertising

CRAFT AWARD

International Core Campaign

Sponsored by Nitrogen Interactive - A Huntsworth Health Company

PositionCampaignCompanyAgency
WinnerNeuroblocEisai EuropeLangland
Highly CommendedLocoidAstellasWoolley Pau
CommendedAnaphylaxisAlk-AbelloLangland
NominatedFerinjectVifor PharmaEuro RSCG Life
NominatedZinerytAstellasPAN Advertising

CRAFT AWARD

Patient Information Campaign

Sponsored by KantarHealth

PositionCampaignCompanyAgency
WinnerReal DangerPfizerLangland
Highly CommendedKid KBayerLangland
CommendedKogenateBayerLangland
NominatedChildren's VaccinesSanofi Pasteur MSDAdventis Health
NominatedDiabetes Awareness (kids)sanofi aventisEuro RSCG Life